Cookie preferences

Analytics and marketing cookies are on unless you switch them off here. Read the cookie policy.

Strictly necessary Always on

Needed for the site to work, such as security and remembering your cookie choice.

Help us understand which pages are useful and which companies visit our site, so we can improve it.

Used to measure our adverts and show relevant adverts on other sites.

Bringing payroll in-house: a guide for small businesses with no payroll experience

Bringing payroll in-house: a guide for small businesses with no payroll experience

Bringing payroll in-house means your own team runs the pay run, instead of sending the numbers to an outside provider each month. For a small business with salaried staff and a monthly payroll, it can cost less and remove a lot of double entry. It also means someone in your team has to own payroll, which can feel scary when people’s pay depends on it.

In short:

  • In-house payroll suits small businesses with predictable pay: salaried staff, one monthly pay date, few starters and leavers.
  • When you run payroll yourself, you send HMRC a Full Payment Submission on or before each payday, pay HMRC by the 22nd and give every employee a P60 by 31 May.
  • List every pay element before you move, including overtime, bonuses, salary sacrifice and benefits in kind.
  • Compare the full yearly cost of HR and payroll together, then run one or two payrolls in parallel before you switch.
  • Choose HR and payroll built on the same employee record, so leave and changes are entered once.

A typical case: a small company of a few dozen salaried staff, with an HR system for documents, appraisals, holiday and sickness, and payroll outsourced to a provider. The person asked to look into small business payroll options has never run a payroll before, and wants HR and payroll both in one rather than paying for two separate subscriptions.

This guide is for anyone in that position. It covers whether in-house payroll suits you, what HMRC expects from you, what to list before you move, and how to switch without risk.

Why small businesses bring payroll in-house

The reasons are usually a mix of these:

  • Cost. You pay for an HR system and, separately, for a payroll service. Once both bills are added up, running payroll in software you already use for HR can work out cheaper.
  • Double entry. Sickness, holiday, starters and leavers are recorded in the HR system, then sent to the payroll provider to be entered again. Every change is typed twice.
  • One place for everything. One system for employee records, leave and payroll means one login, one set of data and one supplier.
  • Control and timing. Changes can go into payroll right up to your own cut-off, without waiting for a provider to process them.

Is in-house payroll right for your business?

In-house payroll suits you best when your payroll is predictable. Good signs:

  • Everyone is salaried, or hourly pay is simple.
  • You pay monthly, on one pay date.
  • Starters and leavers are few, and pay queries are rare.
  • The extras are well known: overtime, bonuses, time off in lieu, a salary sacrifice scheme or two.

It is harder when you have weekly and monthly payrolls, many shift patterns or hundreds of pay elements. If that is you, see our guides to weekly payroll for shift workers and when payroll outsourcing is the right choice.

You do not need to be a payroll expert to run a simple payroll in good software. You do need to know what HMRC expects, and to have someone to ask when an unusual case comes up, such as a redundancy or a first maternity leave.

What HMRC expects when you run payroll yourself

When you run payroll yourself, these jobs move from your provider to you. According to GOV.UK’s guide to running payroll, each time you pay employees you record their pay, work out deductions and employer National Insurance, give them payslips and report to HMRC.

What Deadline Source
Full Payment Submission (FPS) On or before each payday GOV.UK
Employer Payment Summary (EPS), to claim back statutory pay or if you paid nobody that month By the 19th of the following tax month GOV.UK
Pay PAYE tax and National Insurance to HMRC By the 22nd of the following tax month, or the 19th by post GOV.UK
P60 to every employee By 31 May GOV.UK
Report expenses and benefits By 6 July GOV.UK
Pay Class 1A National Insurance on benefits By 22 July, or 19 July by post GOV.UK

Pensions. If you offer a workplace pension, contributions go to your provider every pay run. Every three years you must re-enrol eligible staff and complete a re-declaration of compliance, according to GOV.UK.

Good payroll software does the calculations and the submissions. Your job is to make sure the data going in is right and that someone checks the result before it is paid.

List your pay elements before you move

Before you switch, write down everything that appears on a payslip apart from basic salary. In a small business this is often a short list:

  • Overtime, and how its rate is worked out
  • Time off in lieu, and who approves it
  • Bonuses, for example for staff who work at events
  • Salary sacrifice schemes, such as cycle to work
  • Benefits in kind, such as private medical insurance
  • Pension contributions, from the employee and the employer

Benefits in kind deserve a closer look. HMRC is bringing the reporting of most benefits in kind into payroll in phases, starting from 6 April 2027, according to GOV.UK. If you provide a benefit such as private medical insurance, check which phase it falls into and make sure your new payroll can handle it. Our guide to mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind has more detail.

How to bring payroll in-house without risk

1. Compare the full cost. Add up what you pay today for HR and payroll together, including any year-end or setup fees. Then ask each supplier for two quotes: one where you run payroll in their software, and one where they run it for you. You will see both options side by side.

For example, at Givver’s published prices (excluding VAT), a company of 40 people paid monthly would pay:

Option Calculation Cost a year
Payroll Core, with HR (People Core) included 40 payslips × £5 × 12 months £2,400
Payroll Pro, adding multi-entity payroll and the Xero integration 40 payslips × £6 × 12 months £2,880

Compare that with what you pay today for your HR system and your payroll provider together. See pricing.

2. Check your contract dates. Before you commit, check the renewal date and notice period of your current HR system and your payroll provider. It is easy to renew one just before you decide to replace it.

3. Choose your start date. Starting at the beginning of a tax year (6 April) is the simplest, because there are no year-to-date figures to carry over. You can also switch mid-year, as long as year-to-date pay and tax are moved across and checked. See switching payroll providers mid-year.

4. Run in parallel first. For the first month or two, run payroll in the new system alongside your current provider and compare the results line by line. You learn the system without any risk to anyone’s pay.

5. Use two pairs of eyes. Have one person prepare the payroll and another approve it. In a small team this might be the person who runs HR and whoever signs off the budget.

6. Bring the decision-maker in early. Whoever approves the budget will want to see the system and the numbers. Show them the comparison and a parallel run, not just a demo.

What to look for in HR and payroll software

If you are moving payroll in-house to get rid of double entry, choose a system where HR and payroll are built together, by the same team, on the same employee record. When HR and payroll are separate products joined by an integration, gaps show up on payday: a missing National Insurance number, a date of birth in the wrong format, or a change that did not sync.

Questions to ask:

  • Does leave, including sickness, go straight into payroll once it is approved?
  • Are tax code changes taken from HMRC notices, or typed in by hand?
  • Does it explain why someone’s pay changed from last month, before you approve?
  • Can it send pension contributions to your provider?
  • Does it produce journals for your accounting software?
  • Can you speak to a person when you have a payroll question?
  • Can you turn on only the parts you need, and add more later?

How Givver helps you bring payroll in-house

Givver is UK HR and payroll software for small and growing businesses: HMRC-recognised payroll for small businesses that you run yourself, or that Givver’s specialists run for you. HR and payroll share one employee record, so approved changes such as leave and salary changes are already there when payroll runs.

  • Checks before approval. Large changes and missing data are flagged before your team approves, with the reason for each change. See payroll accuracy.
  • Approval levels. One person reviews, another approves. See payroll approvals.
  • HMRC updates. Tax code changes come from HMRC’s P6 and P9 notices.
  • Pensions and statutory pay. Auto-enrolment and pension contributions are handled in payroll, and statutory payments are included. See pensions.
  • Accounts and calendars. Payroll journals go to Xero, and people can connect their own Google or Outlook calendar. See integrations.
  • A safe switch. Your setup is tested against your own past payrolls before anyone is paid from it, at any point in the tax year. See switching payroll provider.
  • Help from people. Payroll support comes from CIPP-qualified experts. If you would rather not run payroll yourself, a named Givver specialist can run it for you with managed payroll.

FAQs

Is it cheaper to run payroll in-house?

Often, for a small business with a simple monthly payroll, especially if you already pay for HR software that can also run payroll. Compare the total yearly cost of HR and payroll together, and include the time your team will spend each month.

How much does payroll software for a small business cost?

It depends on the supplier, so compare the yearly total for HR and payroll together. Givver’s payroll is priced per payslip, excluding VAT: £5 on Payroll Core, with HR included at no extra cost, or £6 on Payroll Pro for multi-entity payroll and the Xero integration. Givver’s HR on its own (People Core) is free for companies with fewer than 25 employees. See pricing.

Can I bring payroll in-house in the middle of the tax year?

Yes. Year-to-date pay and tax for each employee must be carried across and checked, so the first payroll in the new system continues correctly from your provider’s last one. Starting on 6 April avoids this step.

Do I need payroll experience to run payroll in-house?

Not for a simple payroll in good software, but someone must own it. They need to know the monthly HMRC deadlines, check each payroll before it is paid, and have someone to ask about unusual cases.

What does HMRC need from me each month?

A Full Payment Submission on or before each payday, an Employer Payment Summary by the 19th when you need one, and payment by the 22nd of the following tax month.

Can I contact the Givver team if I have a question?

Yes. Every customer can reach the Givver team, Monday to Friday, 7am to 8pm UK time, with payroll support from CIPP-qualified experts. That includes payroll questions such as statutory pay and HMRC notices, as well as setup and training. See customer support.

This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. For a specific situation, speak to HMRC or a payroll adviser.

Payroll feels scary because people’s pay depends on it. With predictable pay, the right software and a parallel run before you go live, bringing it in-house is a manageable change. Talk to us about your payroll.

Payroll and HR on one employee record.

See how Givver would work for your team.

Talk to sales Or start for free →